10 Best Block Island Restaurants

Block Island is a beautiful small getaway point in Rhode Island. Surrounded by the ocean, the island offers travellers some of the best Block Island beaches, Ocean views and resting places.

For foodies, Block Island is a gastronomic treasure trove that goes beyond its picturesque beaches and idyllic landscapes.

You will find tons of great Block Island restaurants, from upscale dining experiences like Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill, known for its fresh, locally-sourced seafood, to cozy cafes like Persephone’s Kitchen, offering vegan-friendly options and divine melts.

Whether you’re craving pan-Asian flavours or looking for classic New American dishes, the island has something for every palate.

With many of the restaurants sourcing ingredients locally, the food is as fresh as the ocean breeze, making Block Island a must-visit for any foodie. Here are 12 best restaurants on Block Island that you must check.

If you’re not sure to how to reach this island, we have blog for that talks about how to get to block island.

1. Poor People’s Club

📍 Where to find? 33 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham, Block Island

The American-style food at Poor Peoples Pub stands out as some of the most delicious on the island. While it may strike you as your typical run-of-the-mill pub, similar to most other pubs on the island, at first glance, however, the food here outshines any other “pub food.”

Their menu offers many good options, such as burgers, BBQ, local seafood, and pizza. Amid the variety of favorites, a must-try choice is unquestionably their renowned roasted pork chop.

Visitors can go for either indoor or outdoor dining experiences. A sheltered deck and a sun-drenched patio surround the open-area outdoor dining area.

Poor People’s Club is an excellent choice for those looking to catch a game, featuring many flat-screen TVs.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ❌ Price Range – $15-30 Cuisines – American and Pub

Drinks – Cocktails, Beer and Wine Dietary Options – Vegetarian, Vegan, and Gluten Free Options Entertainment – Live Music

2. Tigerfish

📍 Where to find? 126 Corn Neck Rd, New Shoreham, RI 02807, United States

TigerFish offers a refreshing departure from the usual findings on Block Island. Specializing in Asian cuisine heavily influenced by Asian street food, they infuse unique twists into their menu.

Situated ideally, this restaurant is just a short walk away from the beautiful white sandy beach, offering both indoor and outdoor dining options.

The skilled chefs prepare exquisite dishes that go beyond usual. Their Tigeroll with Faroe island salmon, avocado, mango, crab, and tobiko sauce is something to die for, and we loved it the most.

Additionally, they fully embrace their stunning ambiance, complementing their food with a selection of impressive Tiki Bar cocktails.

With a family-friendly ethos, TigerFish goes the extra mile by accommodating even your four-legged companions, making it one of the few pet-friendly restaurants on the whole island.

The warm decor oozes liveliness and energy, featuring live DJs on Thursday and Friday evenings throughout the summer.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ❌ Price Range – $10-30 Cuisines – Asian, Pub

Drinks – Cocktails, Beer, Wine, and Non-Alcoholic Dietary Options – Vegetarian, and Vegan Options Entertainment – ❌

3. Mohegan restaurant and Bar

📍 Where to find? 126 Corn Neck Rd, New Shoreham

The Mohegan Restaurant and Bar is one of the best tavern situated just opposite to the Block Island Ferry Terminal. The restaurant offers New England charm through its cozy dining room and bar, complimented by the splendid views of Old Harbor.

Their diverse menu boasts American pub food, highlighting local seafood, salads, Angus beef burgers, and both hot & cold lobster rolls.

The restaurant also provides a full bar experience with a selection of craft beers, wines, and other spirits. They serve various dietary needs, offering vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options.

Although the Mohegan is a seasonal restaurant, it stays open 7 days/week during the season and serves amazing food.

We absolutely loved eating there, especially their Chicken Caprese salad with Tomato, fresh Mozzarella slices, greens, and perfectly seasoned and cooked chicken strips.

If you want to eat something good and have a good drink to wash everything down, The Mohegan Restaurant and Bar is the ideal spot.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ✔️ Price Range – $15-35 Cuisines – American, Seafood, and Pub

Drinks – Cocktails, Beer and Wine Dietary Options – Vegetarian, Vegan, and Gluten Free Options Entertainment – TV

4. Three Sisters

📍 Where to find? 443 Old Town Rd, New Shoreham

Do you like sandwiches? If you do, Three Sisters is a perfect and affordable option for you. Operated by 3 sisters, which is evident by the name, this restaurant is one of the best on the island, with really good ambiance and decor.

This retro, smallish roadside cottage boasts vibrant yellow accents and a flower box beneath every window.

With the cottage and the laid-back outdoor seating, the picturesque scenery alone is bound to capture the attention of passersby and draw them inside.

We loved their Twister Sister and Sailor Sister, a dish made with tuna, fresh greens, mayo, and more.

They have a cute and colorful chalkboard menu displaying their sandwiches and a few salads. They also offer vegetarian and vegan choices.

You can sit at shaded picnic tables on the grass. There’s also a hammock but that’s rarely empty and but if you find the chance, you’ll enjoy your meal even more.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ❌ Price Range – $5-15 Cuisines – New American

Drinks – Beer and Non-Alcoholic Dietary Options – Vegetarian, Vegan Options Entertainment – ❌

5. Kimberly’s

📍 Where to find? 238 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham

Kimberly’s is a well-known restaurant located in New Shoreham, Block Island. Specializing in seafood, Kimberly’s offers a menu suited for all types of eaters, including vegetarian and vegan.

The ambience of Kimberly’s can be described as a blend of sophistication and comfort. The restaurant’s location provides diners with a picturesque view, sweetening their dining experience.

Some of the special dishes include lobster bisque, bouillabaisse, and Ahi Tuna dusted with Coriander.

The outdoor patio area, in particular, stands out, offering customers a chance to dine in the calm surroundings of Block Island.

The grand Linden Trees provide a canopy of shade, making the outdoor seating area a pleasant spot, especially during the warmer months.

In addition to its culinary delights and scenic views, Kimberly’s is also praised for its superior service. The attentive and friendly staff ensures guests have an unforgettable dining experience.

Whether you’re a local or a visitor to Block Island, Kimberly’s promises a dining experience that combines delicious food, a warm atmosphere, and breathtaking views.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ❌ Price Range – $15-40 Cuisines – American and Seafood

Drinks – Cocktails, Beer and Wine Dietary Options – Vegetarian, Vegan, and Gluten Free Options Entertainment – Television

6. Winfield’s

📍 Where to find? 214 Corn Neck Rd A, New Shoreham

Tucked away in the heart of New Shoreham, Winfield’s Restaurant stands out as a culinary jewel on Block Island.

The ambience inside Winfield’s seamlessly marries sophistication with warmth. Its decor, marked by subtle elegance, creates an inviting atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for both romantic dinners and family or friends gatherings.

Specializing in a delightful fusion of New American classics and fresh seafood, dishes like the Seared Tuna with watercress and chimichuri showcase Winfield’s commitment to flavour and innovation. They also serve cocktails, wine and beers in case you want to get tipsy.

Beyond the interiors, its prime location on Block Island suggests that diners are treated to quiet and picturesque views, adding a touch of nature’s charm to the dining experience.

However, it’s not just the food and ambience that make Winfield’s a peachy place. The restaurant’s dedication to impeccable service is evident. We loved the staff’s attentiveness and genuine hospitality.

In essence, Winfield’s Restaurant offers more than just a meal; it presents a holistic dining experience.

From its expertly prepared dishes and elegant interiors to the potential of enjoying Block Island’s natural beauty and unparalleled service, Winfield’s promises a wholesome evening of fun and fulfilment.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ❌ Price Range – $12-36 Cuisines – American and Seafood

Drinks – Beer and Wine Dietary Options – Vegetarian, Vegan, and Gluten Free Options Entertainment – Television

7. Eli’s

📍 Where to find? 456 Chapel St, New Shoreham

Eli’s restaurant has been since 2017 serving great food to both locals and tourists. This small place has only eleven tables yet offers an intimate and extraordinary dining experience.

We were absolutely delighted to have eaten here. The food tasted good and fresh. The cocktails here are”spot on,” and their Statler chicken with an unusual fried chickpea cake (which we never had before) hits differently. Their steak entree made our evening.

The restaurant’s menu, though small, is smartly created, ensuring each dish is a mix of creativity and flavour. For instance, Eli’s burger has been a hit among many.

This spot is so popular that you’ll have a hard time finding reservations, and as a result, you may not get to enjoy this rather small yet incredible Block Island restaurant.

Near Ballards Beach, you can have a nice calming day at the shore, enjoying the sun and ocean and have lunch at Eli’s, just a few minutes walk away.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ❌ Price Range – $14-30 Cuisines – American and Seafood

Drinks – Cocktails, Beer and Wine Dietary Options – Vegetarian, and Gluten Free Options Entertainment – Television

8. Block Island Oyster Bar & Grill

📍 Where to find? 251 Spring St, New Shoreham

Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill, closely related to Kimberley’s, is a local gem and one of best Block Island bars. Run by four passionate owners, each with their unique touch and a collective experience spanning over 30 years, the Resto and bar primarily offers seafood, freshly caught and sourced daily from local waters.

This place is a little pricier compared to the average prices on the island, but what you’re paying is the premium for freshly sourced and great quality seafood.

Their menu paints a flashy picture of oceanic cuisines infused with flavours from around the world and is a testament to its culinary finesse. Foods like Lobster Taco, sesame-seared tuna tacos, and Salmon Salad.

Even if you don’t fare well with seafood, you will find plenty of other options here, for instance, Blackened chicken mac and cheese and a juicy grilled New York sirloin.

Among their specialities are diverse Oyster dishes paired with expertly grilled fish and mouth-watering selections of steak and lamb.

One of the best things about dining at Block Island Oyster Bar is enjoying the meals while soaking in incredible ocean views. And for a touch of local charm, some nights feature island musicians, adding rhythm and soul to the dining experience.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ❌ Price Range – $7-30 Cuisines – American, Seafood, Grill

Drinks – Cocktails, Beer and Wine (Full Bar) Dietary Options – Vegetarian Option Entertainment – Television

9. Persephone’s Kitchen & Cafe

📍 Where to find? 456 Chapel St, New Shoreham

Located a few minutes walk away from the Block Island Beach House and the Ballards Beach on the streets of Block Island, Persephone’s kitchen is a small coffee shop and eatery in a typical Block Island style.

The colourful wooden door is decorated with small posters, coral flower pots and a handmade sign that takes you back to the 90s. Here, you’ll get the feeling of familiarity, of home, when entering this place.

It may not have the grandness of a traditional restaurant, but it has carved out something truly remarkable and managed it with dazzle. It’s a warm, community-centric place, perfect for sharing a meal with friends. When eating at this place, order their smoothie bowl for a refreshing change.

This small cafe has a menu that will satisfy most of the locals and tourists. The aromatic coffee brewing in the background, delicious breakfasts, and other mouth-watering delicacies will put your senses at ease.

This spot is seasonal and opens only a few months a year during summer, and as the weather gets colder, the restaurant shuts down.The intimate space has limited indoor seating, complemented by a few outdoor tables. They also offer takeaway, allowing patrons to carry a bit of Persephone’s magic wherever they go.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ✔️ Price Range – $4-10 Cuisines – American, Cafe

Drinks – Coffee, Beer and Wine Dietary Options – Vegetarian, Vegan, and Gluten Free Options Entertainment – Chalkboard drawing

10. The Oar

📍 Where to find? 221 Jobs Hl Rd, New Shoreham

The Oar is an excellent spot for both dining and sipping on cocktails. They offer plenty of outdoor seating on the lawn, complete with wooden chairs, picnic tables, and shaded umbrellas.

Additionally, they provide an indoor seating area that feels breezy and open. The spot is made for all, whether you’re coming with friends or family.

There’s a big lawn where children can play, and sitting arrangements allow everyone to enjoy their meals in the open. For added entertainment, they’ve set up a few cornhole games for guests to enjoy. Their salad with chicken is quite popular and we must say, for a good a reason.

It’s a family-friendly venue with a spacious lawn where children can play while parents await their meals. They’ve set up a few cornhole games for guests for added entertainment.

This restaurant stands out from the rest because of its numerous wooden oars-decorated walls inside out. If you look closely, you’ll realize each Oar has a message left by the visitors.

When at the venue, go to the Sushi bar, where you’ll find a wide range of sushi rolls waiting to be eaten. Also, when munching down, ask for their speciality drink, Mudslide.

You can also write a message on an Oar and hand it over to the reception and they will put it on display.

🍳🍽️ Restaurant Information

Seasonal – ❌ Price Range – $7-15 Cuisines – Seafood

Drinks – Cocktails, Beer and Wine Dietary Options – Vegetarian, Vegan, and Gluten Free Options Entertainment – Play Cornhole

Honorable Mention: Old Post Office Bagel Shop

📍 Where to find? 123 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham

The Old Post Office Bagel Shop is a popular quick breakfast and brunch spot. This place is so popular that you’ll find a long queue outside almost every day, but don’t let that deter you, as the efficient staff is lightning fast and you’ll have your order in no time.

The bagels here are second to none. Their sandwiches, muffins, and other quick-fix food items are superbly created, and you can sense the dedication with each bite.

The coffee and baked goods, especially the muffins and chocolate croissants, are praiseworthy and make your waiting worthwhile.

We loved the old classic decor; it takes you back a few decades if you sit indoors. However, if you want to sit in the open, there are outdoor seating arrangements too.

The outdoor area is particularly preferred, allowing children to play while families dine. If this spot is on your list, make sure you set an alarm and visit this place early as their menu tends to sell out very often.

Conclusion

Block Island is a place of gorgeous views, calmness, and great food. There are tons of restaurants on this island. Whether planning a family dinner, catching a game with your buddies, or going on a romantic dinner, there’s something for everyone.

You’ll find great food, diverse cuisine, freshly sourced items, and a nice and friendly environment in all the restaurants.

We have handpicked 10 restaurants that we personally went to. Please do not consider them an official ranking, as the views are our own, and we are sharing them to help you see what you can expect.

Of course, different people have different preferences and tastes, so explore more and write to us telling us what we missed and what we must try on our next visit.